The Great Pumpkin Pie Bake Off
Posted: August 16th, 2009 | Author: Berni | Filed under: Home Cooked, Ingredient, Uncategorized | Tags: Competition, Pumpkin | 3 Comments »
The pies. Chico’s soft and delightful creation above, my sassy, tangy offering below.
There has been much talk of having a bake off. There has been trash talk, psyching out and general teasing and taunting. And then the day came. There was baking, cooling, debating of accompaniments to be served and then……. the judging. Chico and I have had a longish standing debate about who could bake the best Pumkin Pie, so we decided to take it to the next level and have a tasting. I was freaking as I frantically baked the night before the big day, measuring and timing, trying my hardest to stay cool under the pressure. I was confident when I arrived, until I saw and smelt Chico’s effort, he said he would bring it, and bring it he did.
The judges were eager, and as their fervor rose my nervousness did the same. As the pie was sliced and plated up, the sour cream added as the decided upon accompaniment, it was time for the truth. Too nervous to hear the comments I sat in the other room savoring the slices of pumpkiny perfection. Whose pie would I vote for? While I do love my lemony, zingy, kooky kid on the block, it was Chico’s soft and smooth, pumpkin dream that was really taking my fancy, much to my horror and defeat.
I think I knew in my heart of hearts which pie was going to rise triumphant, and just as I thought, Chico trumped me by one point. Was a I disappointed? Yes. But no worthier competitor could I have faced. Chico, you now have and honestly deserve the title, Pumpkin Pie King.

The judges discuss the finer points of each pie.

crisp winter morning